certifired_img

Books and Documents

Current Affairs (28 Jan 2016 NewAgeIslam.Com)


Shades Of Hindutva– Examining Challenges From Within And Without

 

 

 

 

By Tufail Ahmad, New Age Islam

28 Jan 2016

Hindutva, a stock of knowledge and way of life unique to Indian civilisation, is being viewed differently and is facing challenges from within and without. On January 21, M. Venkaiah Naidu, India's Minister for Parliamentary Affairs, tweeted: "Feeling immensely motivated by seeing the great Hindu monk of India, Swami Vivekananda, who has taken…[the] message of Hindutva across the globe."1 Naidu made the comment after visiting the Vivekananda Rock Memorial in Kanyakumari. In this sense, Hindutva is seen as a universal way of life, and was presented in this meaning by Swami Vivekananda at the Chicago Parliament of the World's Religions in September, 1893. In Chicago, Vivekananda had stated: "We believe not only in universal toleration, but we accept all religions as true."2

On January 25, Ramachandra Guha, a noted Indian historian who describes himself as a "lapsed Marxist", tweeted: "I admire aspects of Hinduism and am a Hindu too… I am opposed to Hindutva and Hindu bigotry."3 Guha's tweet got a rejoinder the same day from Sudhanshu S. Singh who works in the humanitarian sector: "There are no clear-cut definitions of Hinduism and Hindutva. Often people abuse Hinduism in the name of Hindutva."4 In short, Hindutva – as a way of life, as a corpus of cultural practices, as a civilisation and as a religion and spirituality – has acquired a set of contentious meanings in Indian society.

The English word "Hinduism" does not reflect it completely due to its association with "ism" which denotes "ideology."The word "Hindutva" too is not a complete translation of "Hinduism" insofar as it conveys a sense of ideology. For example, the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) website views Hindutva as an ideological movement, stating: "This movement, Hindutva, is changing the very foundations of Bharat and Hindu society the world over."5 It is immaterial what Hindutva means at the theoretical level. It is consequential how it is being viewed at the normative level. Therefore, various shades of Hindutva emerge at the popular level and are discussed below.

i) Hindutva – A Universal Way of Life: The term "Hindutva" has come to be associated with the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS, or the National Volunteer Organisation). The RSS views Hindutva in terms in which Swami Vivekananda spoke of – as a universal way of life. It views the entire corpus of knowledge and practices unique to India as Hindutva. The RSS sees itself as representing and defending the way of life that has been India's heritage from the ancient times. In other words, the RSS is the custodian of Hindutva. The RSS doesn't have an agenda of its own, but the diverse cultures of India are on its agenda.

While the RSS's understanding of Hindutva is universal in its meaning, the organisation itself has come to be viewed as a sectarian organisation, mainly because the non-Indian streams of thought such as those represented by Muslims and Christians feel threatened. Also, it is problematic that a single organisation should represent the entire diversities of a vast civilisation known as India, or Bharat. Nevertheless, the RSS's view of Hindutva does capture the vast diversities of India. As a result, a host of Hindu organisations are linked with the RSS by its antagonistic critics, whether or not they are organisationally connected to the RSS.

ii) Hindutva – A Secular Way of Life: A second meaning associated with the first definition views Hindutva as a secular way of life. In this sense, it is difficult to separate Hindu cultural practices from their religious conceptions. For Hindus, religion means spirituality, not an organised religion. However, this conception of spirituality cannot be separated from nature. For example, Hindus worship trees, rivers, snakes, cows and all life forms. In a historical sense – a sense in which history represents empirical practices – Hindutva is seen in a paradigm in which culture, spirituality and nature cannot be separated. Since history is secular, Hindutva is therefore secular.

In a recent article, eminent lawyer Ram Jethmalani quoted a 1995 Supreme Court judgement on Hindutva, which states: "Ordinarily, Hindutva is understood as a way of life or a state of mind and is not to be equated with or understood as religious Hindu fundamentalism... it is a fallacy... that the use of words Hindutva or Hinduism per se depicts an attitude hostile to all persons practising any religion other than the Hindu religion..."6  "Throughout India's ancient history, the word Hindu was never meant to denote religion," Jethmalani noted, adding that "Hindu" is the outsiders' term and the British gave a religious meaning to it.7  "Then came the first census of India by the British in 1871 that defined 'Hindu' as an omnibus term to encompass several religions that were not Muslim, Christian, Buddhist, or Jain," explained.8

iii) Hindutva – As Religious Fundamentalism: Most Hindu groups tend to agree over the two conceptions in which Hindutva is vastly diverse –as a universal way of life and as a secular way of life. However, at the empirical level, we are also witnessing groups of Indians who claim that they are Hindus and defy the above two definitions of tolerance and diversity. For example, bands of Hindu youths enter parks and shopping malls to dissuade youths from celebrating the Valentine's Day. Some Hindu groups that are at the forefront of such a fundamentalist movement are: Hindu Mahasabha, Bajrang Dal, Shiv Sena, the Vishwa Hindu Parishad, and others.9 These groups cannot be painted in terms of purely "religious" fundamentalism; their viewpoint is slightly larger and includes both religion and culture.

However, they have also reduced universal spiritualism of Hindutva to a religion. These Hindu organisations have developed a sense of insecurity, which originates from the fact that India has been invaded and ruled by outsiders for centuries but Indians have themselves never gone abroad to attack any other way of life. Dr. APJ Abdul Kalam, the architect of India's missile programme and late president, was precise: "In 3000 years of our history, people from all over the world have come and invaded us, captured our lands, conquered our minds. From Alexander onwards. The Greeks, the Portuguese, the British, the French, the Dutch, all of them came and looted us, took over what was ours. Yet we have not done this to any other nation. We have not conquered anyone."10 The concern of these Hindu groups is valid, but they also do depart from the original conception of Hindutva.

iv) Hindutva – A Type of Jihadism: In recent years, some Hindu groups havedisplayed a militant opposition on some issues. On January 24, 2009, members of a Hindu group – known as Sri Ram Sena and headed by P. Muthalik – attacked women at a pub in Mangalore for violating Indian values, and over a dozen members of the group were arrested.11 Muthalik justified the attack: "In that pub, women were indulging in obscenity, they were taking drugs"; "Even if our sisters had done this, we would have acted like this only."12 Also, a series of terror attacks that took place in India do not appear to have been carried out by Muslims, though the attackers sought to blame Muslims. Abhinav Bharat, a Hindu group inspired by the conception of Hindu Rashtra (Hindu nation), has been linked to such attacks, as discussed by this writer elsewhere. 13

For such groups, Hindutva represents a form of armed doctrine, much like jihadism is for the Islamist groups worldwide. For example, Shiv Sena, a coalition partner with the Bharatiya Janata Party of Prime Minister Narendra Modi in Maharashtra state and the federal Indian government, has gone on to advocate the use of suicide bombers to save the Indian civilisation. On June 18, 2008, an editorial in Saamna, a Shiv Senanewspaper, warned: "Islamic terrorism is increasing in Hindustan [India] and to confront this Islamic terrorism, Hindu terrorism of equal strength has to be evolved. Like the Islamic extremists, unless there are Hindu suicide bombers to protect the nation..."14 On August 15, 2015, the Shiv Sena reiterated this position in an editorial: "Hindus should be able to live in this country with pride and his (a Hindu's) voice should roar like that of a lion. If an answer has to be given to Pakistan extremists, Hindus will also have to become highly religious. To answer Pakistan, Hindus need to become human bombs and invade their country." 15

v) Hindutva – A Dynamic Way of Life: Hindutva is immensely diverse: Hindus worship rivers, trees, snake, men, women, sun, and practically everything. There is a temple in Delhi dedicated to the Saturn. But at the center of it, Hindutva is a dynamic force, open to accept change. For example, a temple was built in Bihar state in the name of cricketer Sachin Tendulkar.16 Similarly, fans of Bollywood actor Amitabh Bachchan built a temple in his name in Kolkata.17  Hindu masses, led by reformers like Raja Ram Mohun Roy, have also abandoned one of their sacred books Manusmriti, particularly with respect to its advocacy of caste system. There are indications that this truly Indian way of life is about to accept transgenders very soon legally.

Dr. David Frawley, an American Indologist, noted recently: "Hinduism… easily blends in with pluralistic social traditions, such as found in democratic traditions today."18 The acceptance of democracy in India by Hindu masses is unique – not seen for example in the Islamic world. This has led to the empowerment of a large number of masses. Millions of lower caste Indians are enabled as equal citizens due to Hindutva's willingness to change and acceptance of democracy. This acceptance results because Hindutva is a way of life willing to accommodate change; it is not merely a religion. It is due to this acceptance that millions of women are being empowered through the Panchayati Raj system. The rise of women in India's public space could be the biggest tribute to Hindutva's acceptance of democracy in coming decades.

Conclusion

Both peaceful and non-peaceful Hindu groups view their allegiance to Hindutva as the common stock of knowledge and way of life – i.e. as a system of ideas and practices in which culture, spirituality and nature cannot be seen separately. From the above discussion, it is clear that sections of people view Hindutva differently. As a way of life some groups are seeking to defend it militantly and therefore are disliked by those whose viewpoints are thus opposed. Some Hindu groups think that Hindutva is threatened by a combination of three forces: Christians, Muslims and liberal Hindus.

In coming years, some form of militant Hindutva is bound to be active because as the movements of ideas known as Islam and Christianity are succeeding in a manner that undermines the way of life known as Hindutva. For example, it is being seen that in case of inter-religious marriages, it is mostly Hindu girls who convert to Islam in order to marry – a phenomenon now known as Love Jihad. Hindus are generally open to marrying across religions without converting, a proposition unacceptable to Muslims. It is also being seen that in districts where Muslims acquire a sizeable population, they assert their religious values in a way that erodes Hindutva.

For example, Hindus of Nalhati village in Birbhum district of West Bengal have not been able to celebrate Durga Puja since 2012 because the local administration has banned it to appease Muslim sentiments.19 This appeasement is necessary for Indian writers and officials to look good, but in the process a vacuum is created in India's discourse that will strengthen the extremist shades of Hindutva, damaging the original meaning of Hindutva itself. This vacuum in India's discourse is being discussed nowadays on social media as “sickularism” – a combination of political correctness, liberalism and Islamism – and therefore poses a real threat to India's cohesion. In the course of such differences, the Indian Constitution must be the acceptable path.

Satya Prakash, the Legal Editor of Hindustan Times newspaper, thinks that the current concerns about aggressive Hindutva groups should be seen as a temporary siege mentality. "Hindutva as a way of life has pre-existed all other religions. If a few thousand people in a country of 1.25 billion people break from the original Hindutva, it does not mean that the entire civilisational corpus of Hindutva is threatened," he says, reminding: "What is important is that throughout history, instead of attacking others, Hindus have stood by their own core values which has saved the Indian civilisation despite centuries of European and Islamic rule over India. Hindutva as a way of life is like the Ganges that will continue to flow."

Tufail Ahmad is Director of South Asia Studies Project at the Middle East Media Research Institute, Washington DC. He tweets @tufailelif

Endnotes

[1] Twitter.com/MVenkaiahNaidu, January 21, 2016. All the English words used in this article have been mildly edited for clarity and standardization.

[2]Swami Vivekananda's Speeches (http://hinduism.about.com/od/vivekananda/a/vivekananda_speeches.htm), accessed January 28, 2016.

[3] Twitter.com/Ram_Guha, January 25, 2016.

[4] Twitter.com/sssingh21, January 25, 2016.

[5]Hindutva: The Great Nationalist Ideology (http://www.bjp.org/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=369:hindutva-the-great-nationalist-ideology&Itemid=501), accessed January 27, 2016.

[6]Hindutva is a Secular Way of Life (http://www.sunday-guardian.com/analysis/hindutva-is-a-secular-way-of-life), accessed January 27, 2016.

[7]Hindutva is a Secular Way of Life (http://www.sunday-guardian.com/analysis/hindutva-is-a-secular-way-of-life), accessed January 27, 2016.

[8]Hindutva is a Secular Way of Life (http://www.sunday-guardian.com/analysis/hindutva-is-a-secular-way-of-life), accessed January 27, 2016.

[9]Saffron outfits plan peaceful protests on Valentine’s Day (http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/ranchi/Saffron-outfits-plan-peaceful-protests-on-Valentines-Day/articleshow/46204444.cms), February 12, 2015.

[10]'Three Visions For India' (http://www.outlookindia.com/article/three-visions-for-india/215962), June 10, 2002.

[11]Mangalore pub attack: 17 held, Ram Sena unapologetic (http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/politics-and-nation/mangalore-pub-attack-17-held-ram-sena-unapologetic/articleshow/4033613.cms), January 26, 2009.

[12]Mangalore pub attack: 17 held, Ram Sena unapologetic (http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/politics-and-nation/mangalore-pub-attack-17-held-ram-sena-unapologetic/articleshow/4033613.cms), January 26, 2009.

[13]Discussing the Phenomenon of 'Hindu Terrorism' in India (http://www.memri.org/report/en/0/0/0/0/0/840/4781.htm), November 22, 2010.

[14]Discussing the Phenomenon of 'Hindu Terrorism' in India (http://www.memri.org/report/en/0/0/0/0/0/840/4781.htm), November 22, 2010.

[15]India's Ruling Party: 'Hindus Need To Become Human Bombs And Invade [Pakistan]' (http://www.memrijttm.org/indias-ruling-party-hindus-need-to-become-human-bombs-and-invade-pakistan.html), September 21, 2015.

[16]A Sachin Tendulkar temple with a life-sized statue in Bihar (http://www.dnaindia.com/sport/report-a-sachin-tendulkar-temple-with-a-life-sized-statue-in-bihar-1921519), November 19, 2013.

[17]"Bachchan temple" causes embarrassment to Amitabh (http://expressindia.indianexpress.com/news/fullstory.php?newsid=583), July 19, 2001.

[18]Essential Facts of Sanatana Dharma (http://indiafacts.org/essential-facts-of-sanatana-dharma/), January 12, 2016.

[19]This is also 'secular' India: Hindus not allowed to hold Durga Puja in Bengal village (http://zeenews.india.com/news/india/this-is-also-secular-india-hindus-not-allowed-to-hold-durga-puja-in-bengal-village_1815551.html), October 29, 2015. 

Tufail Ahmad is Director of South Asia Studies Project at the Middle East Media Research Institute, Washington DC. He tweets @tufailelif

URL: http://www.newageislam.com/current-affairs/tufail-ahmad,-new-age-islam/shades-of-hindutva–-examining-challenges-from-within-and-without/d/106144

New Age Islam, Islam Online, Islamic Website, African Muslim News, Arab World News, South Asia News, Indian Muslim News, World Muslim News, Womens in Islam, Islamic Feminism, Arab Women, Womens In Arab, Islamphobia in America, Muslim Women in West, Islam Women and Feminism, Moderate Islam, Moderate Muslims




TOTAL COMMENTS:-   24


  • We hope Muslims understand our sentiment and live as our guests not as masters
    By Dabangghindu - 3/19/2017 1:06:17 AM



  • Congratulations for a balanced, sweeping analysis of a phenomenon and an idea ... 
    By Rahul Shastri - 11/27/2016 10:12:32 PM



  • Good article. Impossible to cover such an ancient ideology in such a short space, so, a neat effort nonetheless. 
    By Naveen - 2/26/2016 8:46:05 AM



  • A brilliant  and objective analyses of  what Hinduism is. And also the reality of allegations levelled at Hindu society of hating other communities or followers of other religions. A very well written piece.
    By Arun Sharma - 2/25/2016 8:18:59 AM



  • Excellent analysis by Tufail Ahmad.  Please add these facts also: Hindus willingly and enthusistically participate in muslim festival of Muharram.  I have seen some Hindus installing Tajiyas.  I have also seen droves of Hindus going to attend Bale Miyan's wedding festival in the district of Bahraich (Uttar Pradesh). Many go to Dargah of Ajmer Sharif to worship and seek blessings of Muslim Pir.  These are facts despite some Hindu and Muslim groups being at odd with each other. It should be noted that Muslims do not respect nor worship Hindu deities or go to Hindu festivals like Hindus do.
    By Lalit M. Arya - 2/9/2016 9:23:40 AM



  • In the above comment Mr. Ghulam Mohiyuddin wrote ...
    "Hindutva is a right wing ideology which is centered around the beliefs: the entire Indian subcontinent (which includes countries other than India) is the homeland of the Hindus"  Wonder what he was trying to say.
    what does he mean by *belief*?  as if that's some false belief?
    I implore him to turn the pages of history and explore the facts that whatever he tried to paint as *belief* and possibly a WRONG one, is actually the fact.
    HOW can anybody deny that Muslims have entered the BHARATA-land long after the Hindu civilization was born and flourished for centuries?
    By Nandakishore N - 2/7/2016 3:41:41 PM



  • "Hindu masses, led by reformers like Raja Ram Mohun Roy, have also abandoned one of their sacred books Manusmriti" Totally wrong. He was Dr Babasaheb Ambedkar.
    By Amit - 1/30/2016 12:19:23 AM



  • One very significant aspect of Hindutva missed in the article is the music and the chanting of the name of Hare Krishna or Hare Ram Om Shivaye etc to tunes which descend from ancient sages!
    By Himadri Banerji - 1/29/2016 8:51:46 PM



  • @ghulam
    In 1990 Ramdas married Zulfiqar Ahmad, a peace advocate, whom she had met in college. Zulfiqar is the nephew of the Pakistani academic and anti-war activist, Eqbal Ahmed, one of the Harrisburg Seven. Given her father's stature as a senior naval officer, there was speculation that their relationship could compromise India's national security.[9]
    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kavita_Ramdas

    By satwa gunam - 1/29/2016 11:32:36 AM



  • Whatever said and done, mixing religion/language and politics is bad for a pluralistic country. Once we stop doing that and value every single citizen, without indulging in votebank politics, minority appeasement or majoritarian domination will we progress.
    By Comman Man - 1/29/2016 11:20:21 AM



  • Tufail miyan (at my age I can address young as such). In simple terms when Hindustan was named as such with inien, inia all derived from Sindh, all other religions /Abrahamic were negligible, so those who came from outside clubbed all as Hindus.
    All those being worshipped are from nature -friends of mankind. Snake the best friend of farmers, without which rodents will eat all his crops.   I am 78 and over 65 years left village. There would be snake bambi with brick room built around it and on naag panchmi women in finest attire with children milk etc go to worship.  Trees now everyone accepts, sunderlal patwa who started embracing tree movement of virtually tying trees with thread -to start anti tree felling movement. Each that you may wonder funny and superstitious was the best way to tell right from childhood value of all that.
    A Hindu can never be communal or secular because later are frauds. It is natural that for a Hindu Allah, God etc are all  same. He cannot think ill of Quran, Bible etc. I would see almighty in you.
    To cut long story short, compare yourselves born in Hindustan with Arabs. You are humans they are not as human. I have seen from close quarters.
    Universalism came from here, in their own way . Nothing wrong till it does not teach hurting others.
    With best wishes,
    Bhagwat Goel
    p.s. i come from east Punjab/now Haryana, I was 9 in 1947. If any Muslim passes by Hindus he would wish 'ram ram ji', respond would be walekum salaam' and vice versa.


    By Bhagwat Goel - 1/29/2016 11:11:30 AM



  • Dear Tufail,
    In your well written article for large part,  I was so surprised you sacrificed truth when you said,
    "From Alexander onwards. The Greeks, the Portuguese, the British, the French, the Dutch, all of them came and looted us, took over what was ours"
    How come you mention Greek but fail to mention the Islamic kings who looted and destroyed.  Aurangzeb alone has destroyed more than 10,000 temples according to his own edicts that are available even today (look in google).   I suggest you read Will Durant 'History of Civilization' quoting from Islamic chronicles and you cannot blame Will Durant as biased since he heaps praises on Akbar and was hard if any on his own Christian Civilization.
    This only tells me, however tolerant or unbiased a Muslim looks to be, one can never trust them, that is part of upbringing in Islam.
    Regards,


    By Satya - 1/29/2016 11:09:25 AM



  • This article is both informative and objective. My heartfelt thanks to Mr Ahmad for pointing out the distinction between Hinduism (a term coined by foreigners to indicate a religion) and Hindutva, which is more pantheistic in nature; a way of life, unshackled by static laws, rooted in the belief that this universe is kept in order by the principle of change which demands constant adjustment.
    By Savitri - 1/29/2016 9:53:26 AM



  • Very balanced written!!
    By Ravindra Sharma - 1/29/2016 9:30:48 AM



  • Good article. People like Tufail Ahmad are the need of the hour. In india we have presstitutes and communists divide hindus and muslims so that Congress dynasty can reap vote harvest by creating fear psychosis on minorities.
    By kumar - 1/29/2016 8:43:14 AM



Compose Your Comments here:
Name
Email (Not to be published)
Comments
Fill the text
 
Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in the articles and comments are the opinions of the authors and do not necessarily reflect that of NewAgeIslam.com.

Content