FOLLOW US:

Islam, Women and Feminism (18 Aug 2012 NewAgeIslam.Com)
The Status Of The Average Female Pakistani

By Aneka Chohan

18 August, 2012

For a country that has had a female head of state elected twice and claims to be an ‘Islamic Republic’ at heart, the irony is far too cruel

“A woman is like a tea bag — you can’t tell how strong she is until you put her in hot water” — Eleanor Roosevelt.

The treatment of women is based on two simple beliefs in Pakistani society. One, women are subservient to men and that a man’s honour lies, and to some extent, depends on, in the actions of the female members in his family.

Regarding the female status, Islam and its prescribed words about women play a major role. Clearly, women are seen as wives and mothers. Whilst their economic provision is handled and taken care of by men, women are taught to get married and bear children. In a way, the conflicting thoughts of women in Islam and the cultural ideologies about women clash and become a paradox. Like Zeba Sathar said in Women’s Status and Fertility Change in Pakistan: “A paradox arises in terms of the definition of status, as Muslim scholars may argue that Islam prescribes an elevated status of respect for women (particularly mothers) and ensures their guardianship by male kinsmen; but at the same time women are rarely given the autonomy to make their own choices about whom to marry and when, how many children to have, whether to work.”

Women find their freedom restricted, barriers on their behaviour and activities, limited mobility and hardly or limited contact with the opposite gender. In some extreme parts of the country, such as the Khyber Pakhtunkhwa province and Balochistan, women hardly leave their homes after getting married and rarely do they receive the opportunity to meet men outside of their families. Some women are not allowed to make contact with male cousins from the mother’s side since they are not considered to be relatives in a strongly patri-lineal society. As for relatives such as the father-in-law, brothers-in-law and paternal uncles whom they can meet, relations are very formal. Rather than a human being, women are considered to be accessories that can be hidden and controlled when and wherever.

Purdah, more commonly known as veiling, is one example of this. Depending on different traditions, regions, classes and rural or urban areas, women find themselves confined within the four walls of a house. Outside the home, social life normally revolves around what men do. Sometimes, in some parts of the country such as Islamabad and Karachi, people consider a woman to be ‘shameless’ if there are no restrictions on her mobility.

Another reason that reinforces this status of women is in the broadcast media. Women are often portrayed as subservient in TV soaps and films. Although these programmes spark off controversies by showing women working, seeking divorce, or having a voice in the subject of family politics, these programmes also show that these kind of women — who stray from the image of a traditional, quiet housewife — face ‘insurmountable problems’ and find themselves alienated by family members.

Since the inception of Pakistan, the status of Pakistani women deteriorated under the rule of the country’s former military dictator, General Ziaul Haq, who harboured provincial views about women’s social status through selfish means supported by religion. In a country where government sidelines the poor treatment of women and is too busy fighting a war that is proving too expensive, most cases go undetected and unsolved. With a poorly trained police force and no other authority to hear their pleas, women find their last hopes lie with NGOs and human rights groups.

For a country that has had a female head of state elected twice and claims to be an ‘Islamic Republic’ at heart, the irony is far too cruel. On the one hand, people revered the late Mohtarma Benazir Bhutto and on the other hand, unleashed their cruelty on their wives, sisters and daughters.

The problem is not religious, as most westerners think, but cultural. Almighty God, through his Last Prophet (PBUH) and the Holy Qur’an, has commanded mankind to take good care of their womankind and to treat them like human beings rather than the animals some men think they are. However, the tragedy is that the cries of innocent women are drowned thanks to the belligerent and patriarchal booming voices of misogynists.

What we can do is get together and try to get our voices out there. Although non-violent, they must be louder than the sinful bells of extremism that threaten the current and forthcoming generations of Pakistani women.

The writer is a freelance journalist, writer, artist, photographer and a human rights activist.

Source: http://www.dailytimes.com.pk/default.asp?page=2012\08\18\story_18-8-2012_pg3_4

URL: http://www.newageislam.com/islam,-women-and-feminism/aneka-chohan/the-status-of-the-average-female-pakistani/d/8330

 


COMMENTS
  • Respected Mohammed Yunus Sahib(1)
    You said as:
    "in case you have ever read the Qur’an back to back with a sympathetic heart and probed its best meaning as it demands of the believers – and decide for yourself which side of the divide you stand and feel free to leave faith"
    It is the very basic reason that most of the people think Quran is not a clear book though this claim is repeated.
    Quran is a guide to:
    1. A believer.
    2. A sympathetic seeker.
    3. One chooses best meaning.
    No doubt majority in the world does not see any guidance in the Quran.
    BTW how many Muslims understand the Quran in your way?
    Best recipe:
    1. Close all doors and windows opening into your mind. So that you can believe in anything how absurd it may be.
    2. Be sympathetic even your mind is not ready. Tame your mind into blind faith.
    3. Try to find which is difficult by choosing best meaning, discard what is clear. Terrorists take clear meanings.
    4. Absence of sequence, jumping subjects, misuse of pronouns(first person, second person, third person), mistakes in grammar jumbled history, requirement of tafseer, possibility of misunderstanding etc are the qualities of holy text.
    The hearts of UN-belivers are sealed because they don't have belief, have no sympathetic approach, chooses worst meaning, have critical mind.
    Quran ko samajhne ki taufeeq bhi allah jise chaahe deta hai. Aur Taufeque Allah se maangne par milti hai. Kyaa baat hai?
    Agar Aap Hinduon men paida hue hote to shaayad doosri baat keh rahe hote. Ye hamari sitam zarifi hai ki ham doosri side men chale gaye hain? Aye Allah hamen sirate nmustaqeem par aane ki taufeeq ata farma. Ammen
    Why I should probe? Why guidance is buried in mystery? If guidance will come after such a hardship, Quran is not a clear book.
    No further proof needed.
    Allah does not want every body guided.
    As per creation plan of Allah this world is for test. Paradise is the reward for those who pass this test. Whether Allah knows before test(Aalim ul gaib) or will know after test(is ignorant)

    By mohd yunus - 8/22/2012 11:45:48 PM
  • Dear Mohd Yunus. You say: “Those who think of gender equality are leaving large portion of Islam.” Where do you stand? Feel free to leave the faith if you think of gender equality and hold that those who subscribe to this view leave Islam. 

    You say: “Apologist are not leaving a single stone unturned to prove otherwise.”

    I quote to you the following verses of the Qur’an – in case you have ever read the Qur’an back to back with a sympathetic heart and probed its best meaning as it demands of the believers – and decide for yourself which side of the divide you stand and feel free to leave faith – but be careful if you are in a country like Iran, Pakistan, Saudi Arabia – because these country’s do not given this liberty to the Muslims though the Qur’anic message does not impose any such condition, see my referenced article below.

    “The hypocrite men and women are of the same kind. They enjoin the evil, and forbid the good, and hold back their hands (from giving to the needy). They are oblivious of God and God is oblivious of them, and without doubt, they are the deviants (fasiqun) (9:67). God has promised for them as well as the unbelievers (kuffar), the fire of hell and that is enough for them; for them is the curse of God and an enduring punishment” (9:68).

    “Whether you (O Muhammad) seek forgiveness for them (hypocrites) or you do not seek not forgiveness for them (it makes no difference.) Even if you ask seventy times for their forgiveness, God will not forgive them, because they have rejected God and His Messenger, and God does not guide the deviants (fasiqun)” (9:80).

    And never (O Muhammad) pray for any of them (hypocrites) who dies, nor stand at his grave, for they were unfaithful to God and His Messenger, and died as deviants (fasiqun)” (9:84).

    “The nomadic Arabs are the worst in disbelief (kufr) and hypocrisy (nifaq), and more likely to be ignorant of the limits of what God has revealed to His Messenger, for God is All-Knowing, the Wise” (9:97).

     “God will punish the hypocrites - men and women, and the mushrikin - men and women; and God will pardon the believers in One God - men (muminin) and women (muminat), for God is Forgiving, Merciful” (33:73).

     “(God will) punish the hypocrites - men and women and the mushrikin - men and women, who conceived an evil opinion of God; an evil turn of fortune awaits them. God is angry with them and has cursed them and prepared for them hell – a wretched abode (48:6).

    “They (the hypocrites) have made their oaths a cover; they hinder (others) from God’s path, so they shall have a humiliating punishment” (58:16).

    By the way you write with great authority on Islam. What is your background knowledge about Islam other than hearing/listening to the sermons of the ulama or reading the hadith which you consistently conflate with the Qur’an. Are you a recent convert to the faith? If not you have probably descended from ancestors who embraced Islam by reciting the Shahadah but continued to harbour the notions and worldviews of their pre-Islamic faith that they found in many hadith accounts. This has probably left indelible doubts in your mind about the truth, beauty and nobility of the Qur’an – that touches only the pure heart. Dump it if you are so frustrated with it. You have made me write comments upon comment and this has apparently made no impact on you. Your scepticism of this faith seems to remain intense as ever. I was once constrained to refer to you as a wolf in faith wearing the mask of goat, bearing the name of its noble Prophet – anyway, God alone knows what drives you to write comments that either detract from theme or purport to denigrate the faith of Islam. No point saying Muslims are bad and they are leaving faith in droves. Join the bandwagon of moral freedom as elaborated in my fresh comment to you under a different article.

    Ref: .  Any punishment for apostasy – let alone capital punishment is anti-Islamic  

    http://www.newageislam.com/islamic-sharia-laws/any-punishment-for-apostasy,-let-alone-capital-punishment,-is-anti-islamic-/d/5998
    By muhammad yunus (1) - 8/22/2012 10:11:08 AM
  • Islam we observe is based on Quran and hadith. Total sum is woman is thought to be inferior and thoughts are practiced by Ummah. Those who think of gender equality are leaving large portion of Islam.
    Apologist are not leaving a single stone unturned to prove otherwise.

    By mohd yunus - 8/21/2012 11:22:52 PM
  • Holy Quran has asked men to respect women but Islam does not give equal status to women; men are the guardian/custodian of women. Apologists are vainly trying to prove equal status of women.
    By Hasan Abbas - 8/21/2012 3:38:27 PM
  • By and large, the status of an average Indian female is similar.
    By Ashok Sharma - 8/19/2012 3:21:13 AM

Compose Your Comments here:

Name
Email (Not to be published)
Comments
Fill the below text
 
Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in the articles and comments are the opinions of the authors and do not necessarily reflect that of NewAgeIslam.com.