Books and Documents

Islam and Pluralism (29 Aug 2012 NewAgeIslam.Com)

'This kind of behaviour cannot be and should not be tolerated from any minority'


New Age Islam keeps posting the views of so many sane Pakistanis that one sometimes starts wondering why should Pakistan be in the state it is in, the state that these sensible people are writing about, if so many of them are so wise and rational. Actually, the sane elements are a hopelessly small minority. This is what they keep bemoaning. The majoritarianism of the majority gets articulated in the country’s dominant Urdu media and thus remains hidden from the majority of readers of New Age Islam. Even in our Urdu section we try to project the saner viewpoints.


I came across today a quite honest, though you might like to call it shameless, exposition of the majoritarian hubris so rampant in Pakistan. This might make those Muslims who live as minorities in most parts of the world today feel a bit grateful that they are not living in a Muslim-majority country and thus cannot nurse such arrogance and stupidity. But, I know, this would also make many Muslims here in India regret their inability to be so conceited and idiotic.


Whatever your reaction, I would like to share this gem of a write-up with you. This was sent as a response to journalist Asif Daar’s latest Dateline London column in Jang: “Inteha pasand Muththi se bahar” (Extremists out of control). I am hoping that our Hindutva readers would skip this page lest they start getting ideas. -- Editor




By Mohammad Idris Khan

24 Aug 2012


It seems that these days there is no any other issue in Pakistan except issue of HRH Miss Ramsha masihi of Islamabad. Every other person from Washington DC to Islamabad is concerned of HRH. Although Interior Minister, President of Pakistan and all law enforcement forces are taking care of HRH. Foreign funded media and NGOs are trying to score their merit for it. But our dual Citizens are more concern of it to prove their masters of their sincerity.

 Sowing examples of 'sex grooming' matter or sexual abuse of a girl in London they want Pakistan to ignore HRH's matter but I don't see any connection in these matters. Those who are involved in above incident have no right of any consideration and rightly law is taking its course against them. I don't think any Pakistani has any concern about them. Beside it is inhuman act and further they have to respect and follow law of land. If they don't like their law they must leave their countries. In another murder case of their daughter, Pakistani family has been sentence for imprisonment and Court very rightly said that you peoples want to enjoy facility of England but want Rule of your village which is not possible.   If you think that Burning of Holy Book, Blasphemy of Allah SWT & His Prophet SAS and Contempt of Sacredness of above is same as killing of someone by some one other for one reason or the other then you must understand that it is not same. Muslims believe that protecting Honour of their Prophet is more important than their lives or anything. If the Christian girl is minor or mentally compromised then it is duty of her parent to watch her and refrain her to damage or destroy public life or property. This kind of behaviour cannot be and should not be tolerated from any minority. As a citizen of the country she is also daughter Pakistan but all others, they are also bond to follow Law of the land.


They cannot be exempted for any reason. There is another aspect of the incident to attain attention of West to get settled there for their personal reason. There is no doubt that because of Pakistan's prevailing conditions a number of peoples rightly or wrongly want to get chance for Europe and USA. As it is said that these peoples are poor sweepers and cleaners so getting chance to be shifted West is as 'dream come true'. Remember that we never herd other side of story and circulating version of story is unbelievable.




 URL: http://www.newageislam.com/islam-and-pluralism/by-mohammad-idris-khan/-this-kind-of-behaviour-cannot-be-and-should-not-be-tolerated-from-any-minority-/d/8475



  • Regarding Congress and Secularism, 
    Population of minorities in 1941 and 2011

    India = 16%, 20%
    Pakistan = 25%, 2%
    Bangladesh = 30%, 10%
    The Congress has even imported millions of muslims from Bangladesh for a vote bank.

    The minorities in Pakistan were 90% ethnic cleansed in 1947 itself.
    It was the educated muslims of Aligarh who demanded Pakistan.  Ghaffar Khan, and Maulana Azad, who were more religious , preferred to work with Congress.
    It was the Shia muslims, such as Agha Khan and Raja of Mohammedabad, and Shia businessmen who funded the Pakistan movement.  

    The Ahmedis under Zafrullah Khan were in leadership roles in Pakistan movement.  In 1947, the Ahmedis sent in a Jihadi brigade to fight in Kashmir.
    Yahya Khan was a Shia, and murdered millions of Bangladeshis.  Bhutto, also a Shia was an accomplice in this.
    Now that Shias and Ahmedis are regretting their life in Pakistan, they are trying to distance themselves from their leadership role in creating Pakistan.
    Even in Indonesia, recently there are Sunni riots against Shia and Ahmedis.
    This sectarian intolerance is not limited to Pakistan,

    By Barani - 8/30/2012 7:48:21 PM

  • Pakistanis have proved that no state can be created in the name of religion. Pakistan was created as a reaction to Hindu fanaticism and economic dominance. Congress never believed in secularism. In simple words, secularism means separation of state and religion. Two-nation theory was the biggest fraud of the last century. Now Pakistan is hostage to mullahs. So the minorities and shites are doomed in this country.
    By Hasan Abbas - 8/30/2012 6:54:55 AM

  • The Ramsha Masihi case is the last straw and justifies bringing to an  end Pakistan's existence  as a soveriegn nation. The government has not just failed but is primarily responsibile for the state of affairs. The country must put under the supervision of the UN with an International force enforcing law and order.

    By Naseer Ahmed - 8/30/2012 1:54:36 AM

Compose Your Comments here:
Email (Not to be published)
Fill the text
Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in the articles and comments are the opinions of the authors and do not necessarily reflect that of NewAgeIslam.com.