By Shelly Kittleson
April 9, 2019
The Islamic State (IS) might have lost all
its territory in Iraq and Syria, but its ideology has not been defeated.
Al-Qaeda may be able to exploit this situation and stage a comeback, taking
advantage of its local roots along the Iraqi-Syrian border.
Though al-Qaeda and IS have fought each
other across the border in Deir ez-Zor, most Iraqis use the two terms
interchangeably, since the local branch, al-Qaeda in Iraq, eventually morphed
into what is now known as IS.
In Syria, many acknowledge that there is
scant difference between the two groups when it comes to ideology and
oppressive methods. Yet many see al-Qaeda-linked groups as more locally rooted.
Various opposition groups have even allied with them at times in an attempt to
bring down the Syrian regime.
Qaim's Col. Moussa Hamad al-Karbouly,
however, summed up the difference as follows. IS "used religion for
military ends, while al-Qaeda used military means for religious ends,"
making it more amenable to those disillusioned with IS.
Karbouly is a former police officer and
head of the Aaly al-Furat Brigade, which is part of the local Popular
Mobilization Units (PMU) in western Anbar. Al-Monitor has interviewed him
several times before, including after the liberation of his city, and most
recently on April 3 in Qaim.
His father was killed by relatives who
joined al-Qaeda. Karbouly has long tracked local members of the two terrorist
Members of the Karbouly tribe have been
important IS leaders, including Omar al-Karbouly, who, as Al-Monitor reported
last year, worked "closely with Abu Moussa al-Zarqawi as a top-level
leader starting in 2003" and was captured in 2018 by Iraqi intelligence
Karbouly told Al-Monitor he had seen Omar
in a market in Fallujah in 2008 and “grabbed him and put a gun to his head,
handing him over to the police there. But he bribed them to get out and then
bombed my home.”
He told Al-Monitor the names of local IS
members who he said "did not take part in recent battles" and who he
thinks are likely to return to their roots in al-Qaeda.
"We have information that al-Qaeda is
operating" in the area again, he said, mentioning local leaders Tariq
Khalif Assi al-Karbouly and Adnan Sharif.
"They were al-Qaeda leaders who did
not take part in recent IS battles," he added.
"Tariq al-Karbouly, a.k.a. Abu Ahmed,
joined al-Qaeda in 2005," he told Al-Monitor. He was soon "detained
for five years in Camp Bucca. He tried to escape several times. After his
release he returned to making [improvised explosive devices] and has a great
deal of experience in the field."
Some of them have left their families and
fled to the Iraqi desert, Karbouly said.
"Their families are now staying in the
al-Hawl camp after being in the Baghouz region, where having their families was
a problem for them," he said. "Now that their families are safe in
the camps, the fighters can move more freely and faster."
Alleged IS supporters in the Iraqi town of
Tarmiya, meanwhile, grieved the death of a Syrian fighter with the US-backed
Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF). The fighter, known as Abu Ishaq al-Ahwazi, was
killed in January in an attack attributed to IS, according to a security source
from the town. (Counterterrorism expert Hisham al-Hashimi has called Tarmiya
"the center of Salafi recruiting in the Baghdad area.")
Ahwazi had in recent years joined the SDF
to return to his native Deir ez-Zor and to continue fighting IS, though his
friends told Al-Monitor he supported al-Qaeda's ideology until his death. He
was known for being "the first in his area of Deir ez-Zor to fight against
IS," allegedly by killing two Tunisian fighters, area natives told
He had been a Syrian regime officer prior
to joining the Free Syrian Army (FSA).
This correspondent interviewed Ahwazi
several times during his years as an FSA commander, including when he fought in
Idlib and northern Syria after the FSA was forced to withdraw from Deir ez-Zor.
He repeatedly praised former al-Qaeda leader Abu Maria al-Qahtani, calling him
Abu Maria al-Qahtani, an ex-policeman from
Mosul whose real name is Maysar al-Jabouri, served on the Shura Council of
Syria's al-Qaeda affiliate, Jabhat al-Nusra. He advocated early on for its split
Photos of Ahwazi in military attire
continue to be used as profile photos by many from his area. It seems even
Iraqis in former al-Qaeda strongholds grieved his death.
Meanwhile, in the eastern part of Syria now
under the control of the SDF, local Arab sources have repeatedly told this
correspondent that many IS fighters were "rehabilitated" and later
used in the ranks of the SDF. This has prompted anger among many in an area
that suffered a major tribal massacre after an uprising against IS.
Al-Qaeda may find the border area fertile
ground once more, given its history of local recruitment during the post-2003
insurgency. Furthermore, some locals are aggrieved at the Kurdish-led forces,
whom they see as "invaders" of Arab lands. Locals are also
disillusioned with IS, and they reject Syrian regime control — all important
factors in considering the potential for an al-Qaeda comeback.
The SDF has stressed that it cannot handle
the multitudes in its jails, even before tens of thousands of IS fighters,
supporters and their families were unexpectedly found in an area where
"not more than a few hundred" were thought to have been holed up.
One longstanding source, who travels
frequently between northern Iraq and eastern Syria, and is known to be in contact
with the international coalition, told Al-Monitor that Kurdish leaders from
eastern Syria have prevented the international coalition from discussing
providing support to Arab groups in their local areas who are not subordinate
to the SDF.
An attack in late March on regime positions
near Shuheil — an al-Qaeda stronghold even before 2011 — was said to have been
the first in eastern Syria to be claimed by an al-Qaeda-linked group in almost
Hayat Tahrir al-Sham and other groups with
previous or current links to al-Qaeda, meanwhile, remain strong in Idlib, where
millions of internally displaced people from other areas of Syria are
struggling to survive. Abu Maria al-Qahtani is thought to be in Idlib.
If former al-Qaeda commanders with
experience and local knowledge were to "go back to their roots" and
shift to the Iraqi-Syrian border area, where competing forces at times create
grievances and confusion, areas hit hard by IS and the battles to defeat it may
see fluid alliances among outlaws, and those with little to lose may switch
back to al-Qaeda.
Karbouly expects this to occur "within
Shelly Kittleson is a journalist specializing in the Middle East and
Afghanistan. Her work has been published in several international, US and
Italian media outlets.