Books and Documents

The War Within Islam (07 Mar 2010 NewAgeIslam.Com)

India’s Composite Culture: Emerging Threats

What Muslims Need To Do To Neutralise Them

By Sultan Shahin, Editor New Age Islam

One of the pillars on which our composite culture stands is our sense of unity of religions, what Maulana Abul Kalam Azad called wahdat-e-deen. Many thinkers have intuitively perceived a symbiosis between Islam and Hinduism, though not described it as such. But despite this sense of symbiosis, serious threats to our composite culture have emerged in recent years. We have already reached a stage where many mainstream Muslims are shifting, willingly or unwillingly, from the Indian mainstream to Muslim ghettoes, intellectually and spiritually as much as physically. The recent case, the heart-rending story, of a part of India where both Hindus and Muslims informed a department of the government in writing that they cannot live in mixed localities is known to all of us. While sections of both communities are responsible for this state of affairs, I would like to confine myself to introspecting as a Muslim and trying to see if there is something we Muslims can do to improve the situation and neutralise the growing threat.

But first, let me focus a little on the symbiosis of our religious traditions that has sustained us, and kept us together, for centuries and, I am sure, will continue to sustain us in future.

The one Indian saint who saw this most clearly was Swami Vivekanand.

On June 19, 1898, he wrote:

“I see in my mind’s eye the future perfect India rising out of this chaos and strife, glorious and invincible, with Vedanta brain and Islam body.” (Letters of Swami Vivekananda, p. 380).

He explains:

 “Principles that we practise in our day-today life constitute the philosophy of nature and is likely to be a more acceptable religious philosophy of the enlightened future generation. Except in the religious ideology brought by Muhammad, I do not see this aspect effectively and practically implemented and well entrenched. It is my humble assertion that, though Hindu Vedic philosophies are immensely beautiful, without the day-today practical applications and approaches of Islam, they (Vedic principles) may not adequately serve the humanity.”

One of the greatest Islamic scholars and mystics, Ibn Arabi, affirms in his masterpiece al-Fusoos his belief in the unity of all religions: "Beware of restricting yourself to one particular religion and disbelieving in everything else, so that great good would be missed by you, indeed you would miss attainment of knowledge of the affair in the form he is following. Rather be ready to accept all forms of belief. This is because Allah is higher and greater than to be comprehended by one belief to the exclusion of others. Rather all are correct, and everyone who is correct receives award, and everyone who is rewarded is fortunate, and everyone who is fortunate is one with Whom He is pleased."

It is hardly surprising in this backdrop that many Sufi saints in India, among them prominent names like  Mazhar Jan-i-Janan accepted Hazrat Ram and Hazrat Krishna as Prophets of God as Allah has stated in the Qur'an that He has sent prophets to all nations in all ages who preached to their ummah in the local languages. Allama Iqbal, as is well-known, called Hazrat Ram Imamul Hind. No wonder students of comparative religion have discovered passages in Hindu and Islamic literature corresponding to each other almost word for word.

But, while we intuitively realised the symbiotic nature of our religions and remained together, seeking intercession for the betterment of our daily lives from the same saints, for instance, we did not articulate this fully involving the masses of our people. It seems to me, that even Swami Vivekanand did not fully realize the truly great importance of his own intuitive vision. For, he did not develop the idea further. If developed further in his age and time his intuitive insight could have saved India from a century of strife and perhaps the tragedy of partition. It can still save India from future wars that are staring us in the face. But we will need to understand the colossal import of Swamiji’s vision. We will need to flesh out the idea, develop a consensus around it, and try to translate it into reality.

Now what can we, as Muslims, contribute to this project. How can we help reduce the impact of the fanatics and divisive forces in our own community?

The first task before us, admittedly a rather difficult one, is to recognise our own mistakes: the aspects in which we have betrayed our religion’s teachings. The list is long; so I will confine myself here to just a few. God told us in the Quran, our Prophet told us repeatedly in the Ahadees, that Islam is not a new religion; it is the same religion that God has been sending to this planet through tens of thousands of prophets in all parts of the world in all times. We were told that the Holy Quran is merely a reiteration and validation of the messages that were sent before and in some cases are partially or fully lost in the mist to time. We were specifically told not to fall in the trap of considering ourselves the chosen people, a mistake that some of our predecessors had committed and paid for. But we did not listen. We developed an ideology of Islam-supremacism, contrary to all Islamic teachings. We have developed a theory under the tutelage of our jahil ulema that Muslims alone will go to Heaven, all others are going to be consigned to Hell, no matter how righteous. It was the job of our ulema, the scholars of Islam to stop us from taking this route, but the vast majority of them not only did not do so but actually encouraged this phenomenon and continue to do so. Clearly any one who harbours a feeling of superiority over others, indeed even a feeling of contempt for the others’ beliefs, cannot possibly expect to have good relations with them.

Then we have allowed a section of Muslims to spread among us a version of exclusivist Islam that wants us to get away from each and every pre-Islamic tradition. Pre-Islamic traditions like Hajj and veneration of Kaaba sharif are intrinsic to Islam itself. But we are told that we should behave and even look different from followers of all other religions and forego all our local cultural traditions. Indeed we should even stop going to seek intercession from our saints venerated by followers of all religions. We are told this amounts to kufr and that these saints themselves were kafir, deviants and apostates, deserving of being killed. Tens of billions of petrodollars are being spent to propagate this pernicious ideology and we have been silently falling for this petrodollar Islam; we are surrendering our mosques and their imamships to people belonging to this creed. Supporters of petrodollar Islam are becoming more and more aggressive, particularly in the matter of installation of imams from their institutions.

A derivative of this same petrodollar Islam is what is known as Jihadi Islam. This Jihadi Islam is taking away our youth, brainwashing them and turning them into human bombs. It is using some verses of the Holy Quran as weapons of war. We all know that the Prophet had to fight existential battles to safeguard Islam. Had he not done so there would have been no Islam. These verses were revealed then to buttress the war effort. Today they are valuable to us as pointers to the insurmountable difficulties the Prophet had to face in establishing the word of God for us to benefit from. They tell us the story of how he did it. We have to learn from the spirit of generosity and forgiveness he displayed towards all non-combatants and the forgiveness he showed even to the war criminals, some of whom had mutilated the dead bodies of his own beloved relatives.  So there is much we can learn from these war verses, particularly how a Muslim should behave even if he is forced into war. But these war verses are not meant for us to act upon today.

However, while the Jihadi Islam is using these verses to brainwash our youth into following these dictates to the letter even today, the petrodollar Islam helps the process by saying repeatedly from all platforms available to it that every word, letter, comma, full stop, in the Quran is of equally universal significance, clearly implying that the call to war contained there has the same value as the call to prayer, for instance, or the call to righteousness. They have turned Jihad, in the sense of Qital, into the sixth pillar of Islam.

Obviously the petrodollar Islam and the Jihadi Islam are two sides of the same coin. We mainstream Muslims are silent spectators. We are allowing both of them to devastate our societies, create permanent fissures in our relations with other communities. We are allowing them to suck the spiritual content out of our religion and fill it with a desiccated, dry, desert version of Islam in which there is no room for any of the Islamic heritage buildings, any art or music, anything that is cheerful or beautiful.  Incidentally, one of the attributes of God is beauty, but there is only ugliness and strife in the hearts of petrodollar Islamists.

Mainstream Islam is still mainstream. These exclusivist and warring sections are still small, though with the infusion of massive money power they have grown quite aggressive lately.

But if we want to contribute to the safeguarding of India’s composite culture, we will have to take the bull by its horns. Time for dilly-dallying is long past. We will have to go back to our roots, our Quranic roots, our philosophical roots, our greatest saints and their teachings.

WE will have to once again inculcate the broadmindedness of our saints, the generosity and forgiveness, the attitude of gratitude that was the hallmark of our prophet. It has now become a question of safeguarding not only our religion and our composite culture but also our children, our youth from being whisked away to Jihadi camps and active and sleeper cells. The very least we can do to safeguard our own youth as much as India’s composite culture is to explain the following to our community loudly and repeatedly:

1.   That we are not a chosen people; Islam-supremacism is nonsense and that the ummah of all prophets are equal in the eyes of God who will judge them according to their own faith, not ours. It is nonsense to believe that only Muslims will go to Heaven.


2.   That the Holy Quran is not a book that was revealed in one sitting. The war verses in the Quran were meant for wars being fought then and do not apply to situations today. These verses were revealed to the prophet as guidance for the situations he found himself in. As those situations cannot be replicated today, that particular course of action is no longer applicable to us. This is important to defeat the Jihadis who are using these verses as weapons of war to brainwash our youth and turn them into human bombs. 

 3.   That Islam is not the exclusivist religion that the Petrodollar Islam is preaching. It is a religion of co-existence encapsulated in the verse lakum deenakum waleya deen (For you be your religion and for me mine). It is also the religion of La Ikraha fid Deen (There can be no compulsion in religion.)

4.   That the Sufi saints who brought Islam to this sub-continent and to the entire South-East Asia are not, God forbid, religious deviants as Petrodollar Islam proclaims them to be. It is because of them that we are Muslim today. It is they who gave us access to the teachings of Islam. It is not wrong for Muslims to show reverence to them along with people belonging to other communities.


5.   That Islam itself teaches us Ijtihad, rethinking, so that we can adjust to the newer realities of changing times. We have to rethink every postulate of Islam in the light of today’s realities.


6.   That religious freedom is indivisible. If we as a minority community need freedom, it becomes our duty to also fight for the religious freedom of minorities in Muslim lands, particularly in the Indian sub-continent. It is shameful that when two Sikhs were recently beheaded in Peshawar, reportedly for refusing to convert to Islam under compulsion, our ulema remained completely silent. We have been completely unmindful of the plight of religious minorities in both Pakistan and Bangladesh while enjoying full citizenship rights in our country. This must change.

Let us pray that Maulana Abul Kalam Azad’s doctrine of Wahdat-e-Deen once again gains converts. Let us try to flesh out and translate into reality Swami Vivekamad’s vision quoted before: “I see in my mind’s eye the future perfect India rising out of this chaos and strife, glorious and invincible, with Vedanta brain and Islam body.”

 In order to be ready to become a part of the Vivekanad project, however, the Islam body will have to rid itself of the many viruses it is harbouring in its system today.

This essay was presented at a seminar organised by UrduTahzeeb.net on “Terrorism: the response of India’s Composite Culture” in Mumbai on 28 February, 2010.

URL: http://www.newageislam.com/the-war-within-islam/india’s-composite-culture--emerging-threats/d/2545


  • I agree with every word of Mr. Mubaschir Inayet (except the spellings of his name  … just kidding),   who has conveyed the spirit of Islam as we have known it, by living though it over generations.  I wish more of us could converge to these sets of views so that, with a clear head,  the community members could strive to turn this planet into a better world.

    By Manzurul Haque -

  • The Qur'an , while accepting peoples right to follow what ever way of life and religion they choose to, highlights some erroneous aspects that emerge over time and seeks to set the records straight. Some of these are:
    1. There is One indivisible Creator. Man can know Him by His signs but the human brain cannot comprehend His nature, and so to be preoccupied in defining His nature is pointless. This also means God is not someone in the sky you think about and go to sleep. He has given guidance under the broad frame work under which humans must legislate their laws. They include:
    1. All humans are born worthy of respect and honored; it is their bad behavior that demeans them.
    2. All obedience is due to the Almighty alone and no human is superior to another.
    3. Economic exploitation of any kind is wrong; Charging usury falls under this category.
    4. Men and women have their own characteristics; In some ways man are  better than women and in some, women are better than men. They are co-associates and helpers in promoting all that is good for the society.
    5. There is no compulsion in religion. Live and let live. Invite people to truth with courteous preaching and not force.
    6. There is a Day of judgement and humans will be requited to account for their deeds.7. This is a world of temptation and therefore a test. We need to evaluate ourselves each day to see how we are performing against what we claim to live and die by and make corrections along the way.
    8. Fight off aggression and help the oppressed. Be not aggressors
    9. Treat with kindness and respect those who don't bother or fight you and wish you no harm. Observe justice, kindness, benefiting people, helping relatives and the needy, forgiveness, compassion, clemency, trust worthiness, generosity, self control, truthfulness, keeping pledges, service of creation, etc.
    10. Avoid adultery, theft, anger ,stinginess, gambling, intoxicants, murder, persecution, deception, slander injustice, priest worship, having middlemen between God and man, discrimination based on ethnicity, backbiting, name calling, abusing other peoples gods and bad mouthing them. 
    11. Avoid worshiping idols (be they human, images, statues, own selfish desires, priests, holy men, etc). Man is created with honor and idol worship degrades him.
    12. Stand up for truth and justice, even it goes against your own. Mean what you say and say what you mean.
    13. Run your affairs by mutual consultation and when you decide something have faith in God and follow through.
    14. Help those left behind in any aspect in the march of human life. There is a share of the dispossessed and poor in the wealth of rich. 
    15. It is God's plan to allow existence of different ways of life and faiths; Although He could, He did not choose for all to follow One Way. Humans have freedom of choice. Right road leads to right destination and the wrong turn leads to the wrong destination. Therefore, instead of wasting time in violent conflicts over who is right and who is wrong, mankind should co-operate and compete with each other in doing good for humanity. 
    16. The universe is available to man to explore, discover and to subjugate only for the benefit of mankind, therefore, one must not misuse these powers given to man who develops it by research and observation.
    Etc. Etc. and the list goes on but it is better to keep it short.
    Now we have a chance to compare the above (and more) to other faiths and see if there are more similarities or dissimilarities. Yes, the Qur'an says "To you your religion and to us ours" but also rejects unity of religions by saying "What you worship and what we worship (obey) are not the same (to those who wish to claim "all are the same"). How can it be the same when it is more than obvious in our daily lives there are marked differences in attitudes and values of people of different faiths. Qur'an makes it it's business to set the record straight but leaves no room for force and we are free to follow it or reject it. What we choose to do is based on the law of consequences and what we sow, we will reap not only in this world, but the next.
    By Mubaschir Inayet -

  • No place is better than India for Muslims : Maulana Mahmood MadaniMaulana Madani delivering the talk

    Democracy is the greatest virtue and strength of India and no place is better for the Muslims than India, Maulana Mahmood Madani, Leader of Jamiat Ulama-i-Hind, who is also the member of the Rajya Sabha, said on February 21, 2010 evening while delivering a talk on “Terrorism: Response of Indian Ulema”.

    Maulana Madani, known for his stiff opposition to the jihadi brand of terrorism, did not hold back any punches on the subject during his talk organised by the Vivekananda International Foundation at the VIF campus that was attended by eminent personalities from such diverse fields as politics, bureaucracy, armed forces and religious organizations. VIF Director Ajit Doval introduced the subject and the speaker, while former Vice Chief of Naval Staff Vice Admiral K K Nayyar presided over the function. Doval, a former Director of the Intelligence Bureau, described Maulana Madani as a major representative of the ‘Indian Islamic thought’ who had contributed a lot to the national interest.

    The Maulana said there was no place for wanton killings in Islam and stressed that the roots of the problem of what is happening today in the name of Islam are not in India, but outside. “Violent activities in the name of Islam are actually against Islam. This is the greatest unIslamic act. To kill or oppress somebody who is innocent and weak is an unIslamic act and I can give innumerable citations from the Koran and the Hadith,” he argued.

    The Deoband chief spoke extempore in Urdu for about 40 minutes and then answered questions from the audience. He described how the Jamiat Ulama-i-Hind, the biggest organisation of Indian Muslims, launched a movement against terrorism, but quickly added that it was a short-term strategy. He recalled how he was criticised by fellow Muslims and some other leaders of his community who repeatedly taunted him for this and asked whether he had nothing better to do. He said his movement against terrorism was aimed at giving the much-needed make-over to the “Muslims, Maulvis and Deoband” whose image was getting dented by terrorist activities.

    Significantly, in this context, he pooh-poohed the claim of the Taliban leaders that they were ‘Deobandis’. He quoted Maulana Mahmood Hassan, a prominent Muslim leader from Deoband who in 1915 sent his five Maulvi disciples to Afghanistan to wage India’s freedom struggle from there. Maulana Madani pointed out that Maulana Hassan’s disciples set up a government-in-exile and Mathura’s king Mahendra Pratap was made the head of this government-in-exile. Maulana Madani quoted this example to drive home his point, which was Maulana Hassan’s conviction too, that India could be made independent by oneness, by staying together, wherein the citizens keep the national interest supreme by sinking their differences on religious grounds.

    Maulana Madani said the need of the hour was to thrash out a long-term strategy to deal with the menace of terrorism. He opined that the long-term strategy will have to ensure three things for the Indian Muslim community: economic upliftment, education and deliverance of justice – the kind of justice that is not only done but seen to be done also. He also advocated reservations for Muslims to achieve these objectives.

    The Maulana recalled with a tinge of bitterness and regret the utterances of former Pakistan President Pervez Musharraf at a conclave in New Delhi in early 2009. He said he had thought that since General Musharraf was visiting India a few months after the 26/11 terror attacks in Mumbai, he would be applying a soothing balm to the Indians through his words. The Maulana said he was totally disappointed with General Musharraf, who instead of saying a few soothing words “spoke like a General addressing his troops”.

    In response to a question seeking his reaction to the fact that after the Delimitation of Lok Sabha constituencies last year, the number of those constituencies where the Muslim population was 15 per cent or more had risen to 164 from 119 earlier, Maulana Madani replied this was one of the reasons for the Muslim community to feel proud to be Indian. The Maulana also pointed out that India had never been an invader or a colonialist power. Amid thundering applause from the audience, he said India pulsated in its soil and throbbed in its air, something that has to be felt and cannot be taught through any book.

    (Reported by Rajeev Sharma)

    Event Date: 21 February, 2010
    By Ashok Sharma -

  • Hazrat Krishna (or Hazrat Ram) are not prophets.Krishna is the Supreme Personality.This is confirmed in the entire Vedic literature,‘ishvarahah paramah Krishna...’(Brahma Samhita),‘Krsnas tu bhagvan swayam....’(Srimad Bhagvatam),‘aham sarvasya prabhavo mattah sarvam pravartate...’(Bhag.Gita).

          Also if all religions were the same why would there be so much religious conflict.KrIshna explains in the Bhagvat Gita that the reason for conflict is misidentification of our body as ‘self’.The very first teaching of Sri Krsna is that we are eternal ‘spirit souls’,part and parcel of Sri Krsna,‘mamaivaamso jiva butah...’.The ‘spirit soul’ or ‘atma’ is embodied in a Hindu body,Muslim body,Christian body,black body,white body,American body,Indian body,cat body,dog body and so on.But we are not the body.The body is made of dead matter,(earth,water fire,air and ether) but we are ‘spirit soul’,eternal.It is the association of the ‘spirit soul’ with the body that makes it conscious,and when it dissociates from the body, it is technically called ‘death’.‘avinashi tu tad viddhi yena sarvam itam tatam’,Krsna thus explains that the symptom of the ‘spirit soul’ is consciousness.

           The understanding of this basic point is vital if we are to understand the science of God.Unless we give up the religion of ‘bodily designation’ we can never move forward in this matter.

           The entire Vedic literature appeals that the supreme goal of the living entity is to develop a loving relationship with Sri Krsna and not Vivekananda’s vedanta brain and islamic body.

    By deepak Sarkar -

  • Mass hysteria is definitely being created. It is the media which makes it appear as if the Islamist threat is the most dangerous to the Western world.

    Thanks for the facts and truth!

    By juhi -

  • This is a laudable effort! More such conferences should be organised in different parts of the country, for reaching out to the masses with this message.

    By juhi -

  • I went through the article with great interest and it gave me an insight into the true Islam. This is unfortunate that true Islam has been lost in the explosions and screams and wails resulting from them. Today when we talk of Islam the images of gun totting terrorists come to our mind first. And the non-Muslims are not to blame. Because these terrorists have painted a wrong picture of Islam. I appreciate Mr Shahin's efforts to present the true picture of Islam. Kudos!

    By Om Prakash Shukla -

  • When Mr Sultan Shahin says that Muslims should not consider themselves the chosen few and shed the idea of Islamic supremacisM, he forgets that he stays to be a Muslim because he thinks that Islam is the best religion. Or is he  staying as a Muslim because he was born as one. 

    By Iftekhar Raghib -

  • I agree with what Mr Ashok Sharma has said. Mr Shahin is doing his bit to strengthen Hindu Muslim unity by clearing common misconceptions about Islam.


    By Md Mohsin -

  • Great Article!! The idea should now be made available to more and more people.... Mainstream Muslims knows that this jehadi version of Islam does not represent them, but do not have enough material to counter them. Such articles provide the substance.

    By Juhi -

  • Mr Sultan Shahin has fogotten one crucial point before putting this article on the website. Some people have the gift to see through the mask, however thick and disguised it is. Not everyone is a fool.

    By Amir Aslam -

  • Mr. Sultan Shahin deserves the highest level of appreciation for his efforts towards National Integration and Communal Harmony in the country. Unfortunately, not many sections of our media have such positive approach and tend to sensationalise serious issues for larger circulation or, TRPs. Most Indians want to live in harmony as they have more pressing problems related to their survival rather than fight for imaginary concepts and differences. We need to encourage such rational thinkers and activists. Congratulations!

    By Ashok Sharma -

  • I would like to keep my comments reserved on some of the ideas  of Janab Sultan Shahin sahib, even though I also stand for fresh representation of  the interpretation of Islam in words that suit the imperatives of the  present times.

    By Manzurul Haque -

  • Mr. Sultan Shahin deserves congratulations for this superb piece. I agree with each and every word in it. I reserve my right to steal from it at will :-)  

    This speech should be re-published in as many other magazines and e-mags as possible.

    By Ghulam Mohiyuddin -

Compose Your Comments here:
Email (Not to be published)
Fill the text
Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in the articles and comments are the opinions of the authors and do not necessarily reflect that of NewAgeIslam.com.