Books and Documents

Islamic Society (30 Sep 2015 NewAgeIslam.Com)

Once Temples, Now Madrasas: Dars Among Deities



 By Haroon Khalid

 29 September 2015

We stood at the entrance of the temple, not sure if we would be allowed to go inside. It was a double-storey structure with a small round balcony. I stood before a wooden door with intricate patterns, and fading remnants of frescoes on the wall next to it. I could only imagine how beautiful this structure must be from the inside.

The only problem was that this temple was not vacant. It wasn’t even taken over by an individual family, as has happened in so many cases. In that situation, I could have requested them to allow me to see the temple from the inside. But this was now controlled by the women's wing of an Islamic religious organisation called Minhaj-ul-Quran, founded by the famous preacher turned politician Tahir-ul-Qadri.

I rang the bell not sure what would be the response of the people inside. A young boy emerged at the entrance and after listening to our request disappeared into the house. He returned after a little while, saying that they would not allow the men to enter the temple but the ladies with us could come in.

We implored, but the response was final. There was a dars, a lesson of the Quran, under way, in the courtyard, attended only by women. My friend Rida with her camera, and my wife Anam, disappeared into the temple, now an Islamic school.

We were at the historical city of Malka Hans, about 200 kilometres from Lahore, to visit the historical mosque of Waris Shah in the city. Waris Shah is a celebrated Punjabi poet known for re-composing the folk tale of Heer-Ranjha. With his rendition, he managed to leave such a stamp on it that all former versions are forgotten and the story is now known as Heer-Waris. Waris Shah is believed to have written this story in the basement of the mosque at Malka Hans where he used to work as an Imaam.

The temple was across the street from the mosque. In Waris Shah's time in the 18th century, it was not unusual to find a mosque and a temple sharing a wall. Today, of course, that is an anomaly.

There are several stories about this relationship between the mosque and the Hindu temple, about Waris Shah and his Hindu beloved who, it is believed, used to come to this temple regularly. The temple belonged to the sect of devotees of Chajju Bhagat, a 17th century Hindu saint from Lahore.

There were old houses located in this street, which must have once belonged to Hindu families living here. I wondered in what condition they must have left their homes in 1947, temporarily locking their doors, perhaps burying their precious belongings, hoping to return one day.

They never returned, but perhaps they told their loved ones about the homes they left behind and this temple. Perhaps their survivors have fragments of memories of stories they heard about this temple?

Rida and Anam returned after a little while, ecstatic. “It was a surreal feeling,” said Rida. “There were wooden figures all around the temple, perhaps angels, and sitting under them were these women clad in burqa, reciting the Quran. There were pictures of Hindu deities on the wall while these women talked about the unity of God. No harm had been done to any of these idols or figures on the wall.”

These women saw no contradiction in studying Islam in a Hindu temple.

About 200 kilometres from Malka Hans, in the ancient city of Multan believed to have been once ruled by Hiranyakashipu, the tyrant father of Bhakta Prahlada (Bhagat Prahalada, in Punjabi), we saw a similar anomaly. Deep within the walled city, we located a Jain Temple. Even before we entered the main room of the temple we could hear a humming sound of children reciting the Quran, memorising it.

Inside the hall there were rows of mats with small tables in front of them where children had placed their copies of the Quran, rhythmically moving back and forth as they recited their lesson.

The sound of the children came to an abrupt end as we entered the room and all eyes fell on us. “Assalamualaikum,” I said. “Walaikum assalam,” replied everyone in unison. “Can we see and photograph your temple?” I asked. This time, only the teacher replied: “It is all yours.” The students went back to memorising the Quran.

The ceiling of the temple was made with wood, decorated with small pieces of glass. There were beautiful geometrical frescoes on the wall. On one side of the room was a gilded door that led inside the main sanctuary. Near the door were pictures of the 24 tirthankaras, who are supposed to grace each half of the cosmic time cycle in Jain cosmology.

I was too lost in beauty of the temple to notice that the sound of the recitation had stopped. All the children and their teacher had presumably finished their lessons and left the premises.

Later as my friend Iqbal Qaiser and I stood facing the turret of the temple at a shop, drinking a cool bottle of Pepsi, we were told by the shopkeeper that this temple like other temples around Pakistan was also attacked by fanatics in 1992, in reaction to the demolition of the Babri masjid in India.

However, the administration of the temple was able to dissuade the mob from causing much destruction to the temple.

“It is not a temple anymore. It is a madrassah,” they had argued.

Just a little outside the city, located on the top of a mound facing the walled city, once stood the temple of Bhagat Prahlad, the patron Hindu saint of the city of Multan.

The wall of his temple touched the wall of the Muslim saint Shah Rukn-e-Alam’s shrine, the new patron saint of Multan, after the creation of Pakistan. This temple too was being used as a madrassah. After the riots, the madrassah was permanently shut while the temple suffered heavy losses.

Same is the story of the Sitla Mandir in Lahore. In the same building, now, a madrassah is being run.

This article was originally published at Scroll.in and has been reproduced with permission.

Haroon Khalid has an academic background in Anthropology from LUMS. He has been traveling extensively around Pakistan, documenting historical and cultural heritage. He is also an author of A White Trail: a journey into the heart of Pakistan’s religious minorities and an upcoming book In Search of Shiva: a study of folk religious practices in Pakistan.

Source: dawn.com/news/1209541/once-temples-now-madrassahs-dars-among-deities

URL: http://newageislam.com/islamic-society/haroon-khalid/once-temples,-now-madrassahs--dars-among-deities/d/104751


  • To Satbir singh Bedi
    In any age of human history god had never made compulsion to believe him/her(actually their cannot be gender for god).
    It is the humans who had invented, that is why their was Paganism, you have your own god and do not force somebody else to believe your god.
    But when muscle power joined with religions(example Abhrahmic religions)  the have always made compulsion.
    Or tricker like Bhramins of India did for centuries and remain in the power,
    Through out the history of religions who had never imposed and never used muscle power(on the contrary gave his Kingdom) was only Buddha.
    That is the reason buddha teaching spread on the half face of the earth without any violence and still spreading among the western world, because it has non-violence and tricker involved it takes long time to spread because you accept by choice not like christian & Muslim missionaries who use all the means to spread. 

    All problem started n religions when Abrahamic religions started to interfere in the everyday and everyones life.

    If you do not believe in god it is your choice but God is their you find on your own way like Buddha but who I am to advice you. Use your own rational mind.

    I can thousand lines how God had loved the Humans and other creatures and how beautifully design the world for us to get the salvation, this words are nor merely copy or read from the other books, this words come when you infer your day today experience you can see the purpose of your life, unless you do not infer your day to day you will never understand beauty and love of god. 

    At last I will say I am not Buddhist I am Hindu but rather than  candam god I love it with my heart so I try to read the all religious book  and their aspect and try to find the Good and Bad they have done to Humans, their can be chances this books are perverted according to need(mostly political).

    By Aayina - 10/2/2015 3:22:25 AM

  • Dear Aayina,

    I do not go to any place of worship as I consider God to be present everywhere.  At the death of someone, I may sometimes go to a Sikh or Hindu temple but I never pray to God for I think that He is not justice loving.  See what He has done to Syrian refugees?  What harm had they done to God to deserve all this?

    By Satbir Singh Bedi - 10/1/2015 6:43:58 AM

  • From Muslim point of t should not be wondered, that how Islam started it proclaimed it worship place by saying that it was Abraham first Mosque and sentiments of those pagan Meccan was hurtled, anyway How much truth is their in proclaiming that Mosque " God knows better" he will judge better, but claming other religious place has became fundamental right of Muslim. In some western countries church are sold and demilosh those and can use for making anything. Muslim by especially this churches and make mosque and they take pride in it. It not only Muslims but Hindus too do samething. Taking someone else worship place as if has became like pride. I will say Hindus have learned bad from Muslim rather than something good, which every relegions has beat in peaceis .

    By Aayina - 10/1/2015 4:46:09 AM

  • This is not one way traffic.  Many mosques in Indian Punjab have been converted into Gurudwaras (Sikh temples) including in my village, Banga.
    By Satbir Singh Bedi - 10/1/2015 1:45:16 AM

Compose Your Comments here:
Email (Not to be published)
Fill the text
Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in the articles and comments are the opinions of the authors and do not necessarily reflect that of NewAgeIslam.com.