Dr Ellis Silver's Book "Humans are Not from Earth" Is Utter Garbage!
By
Sumit Paul, New Age Islam
6 March
2023
I'm afraid
the article 'Humans Are Not from Earth: The Brilliant Scientific
Research of American Ecologist Dr Ellis Silver Supports the Fact Mentioned In
the Quran' on NAI website is the most puerile and
unscientific piece I've read thus far.
I'm not
criticising the writer who has written it. I'm criticising Dr Eliis Silver's
book which has been discarded by all evolutionary biologists and scientists
across the world.
An average
devout Muslim with no scientific temperament may like this book because it
indirectly endorses what the Quran says.
But any
rational Muslim with even a scintilla of scientific approach and bent of mind
will pooh pooh this book that hit the stands a decade ago and its second
edition was brought out in 2017. The author of this book seems to have been
influenced by the Swiss author Erich von Daniken's outlandish claims of aliens,
space and extra-terrestrial life on other planets. Daniken once claimed that
gods were aliens from far away planets which were already advanced when our
world was in its nascent stage. Dr Silver has also made bizarre claims. You can
drive a coach and horses through the author's arguments.
-----------------------------------------------
Also Read: Al-Insan or The Man
-----------------------------------------------
"Just
a cursory application of high school level science will debunk his claims.
Probably the most obvious is our genetic blueprint. We share at least 96% of
our DNA sequence with chimpanzees and only marginally less with other primates.
To call on chronic backache as evidence of alien descent is just rank idiocy.
His whole theory is at the level of maturity and knowledge of a 14 year old. Dr
Siver’s book is full of pseudoscience and wrong scientific information and
fallacies!
This goes
from low back pain that is due to human being bipedal and not because of too
much gravity! Large human new-born being the cause of new-born death? Where is
the statistics to say that? In fact, full term foetus skull bones are not fused
and extremely malleable. Even animals get back arthritis! So, why don't Lizards
get sunburn? They are coldblooded and will die staying under the sun too long.
Their core body temperature goes up and they die! Mars' complete rotation is 24
hours and 37 minutes, not much different from earth! There are no scientific
references in the book to back his made up story! There was the discovery of
Nucleotides on comets, not on Mars and there is a big difference between
nucleotides and life! It’s unfortunate that some people can be so uninformed
and gullible to believe his sci-Fi like, almost delusional writings! Utterly
unscientific. How could one test that claim empirically? If humans were
"brought to earth" then so were all the primate species related to
humans. How likely is that "? (Courtesy, Journal of Scientific Studies,
NY, 2019).
Just
because a majority of Muslims believe that Adam and Eve were put on earth from
Allah and Adam was banished from Bahisht or Paradise (remember, ' Baagh-e-Bahisht
Se Mujhe Hukm-e-Safar Diya Tha Kyon....' Allama Iqbal), the author's claim
of humans descending from other planets must be a Gospel truth! This is a
ridiculous conceit (a far-fetched idea). Remember, you've every right to
believe in all sorts of stupidity but stop when it becomes moronic and morbid.
-------
A
regular columnist for New Age Islam, Sumit Paul is a researcher in comparative
religions, with special reference to Islam. He has contributed articles to the
world's premier publications in several languages including Persian.
URL: https://newageislam.com/books-documents/ellis-silver-humans-earth-/d/129252
New Age Islam, Islam Online, Islamic Website, African Muslim News, Arab World News, South Asia News, Indian Muslim News, World Muslim News, Women in Islam, Islamic Feminism, Arab Women, Women In Arab, Islamophobia in
America, Muslim Women in West, Islam Women and
Feminism